First up from the God Machine this week is an unexpected story out of Illinois, where a notable evangelical college was faced with a fairly simple choice regarding health care, but where school officials nevertheless made an inexplicable decision.
The Chicago Tribune reported this week:
Taking a firm stand against Obamacare’s controversial contraception mandate, Wheaton College on Friday will stop providing any health insurance for students.The decision, announced to students July 10, will halt health care coverage for about a quarter of the college’s 3,000 undergraduate and graduate students, forcing them to shop for other plans just weeks before their coverage ends.
Now, it’s easy to get the basics of this story wrong. This is not, for example, a controversy in which Wheaton College had to choose between offering health benefits and providing contraception, or perhaps being forced to offer coverage that includes access to birth control, which the religious institution didn’t want to subsidize. Stories like these have come up, but that dynamic doesn’t apply here.
Wheaton faced a very different kind of choice. Under the Affordable Care Act, the evangelical college could claim a religious exemption to the contraception policy, at which point a private insurer would create a separate policy to cover contraception, directly for the consumer. Wheaton wouldn’t have to subsidize this separate plan at all.
The college said this accommodation isn’t good enough — even claiming a religious exemption, it said, is a burden. It’s preferable, Wheaton administrators concluded, to simply impose a last-minute change that scraps student health plans altogether.
Paul Chelsen, Wheaton’s vice president of student development, said the move to cut off students’ health security “breaks my heart,” but he’s doing it anyway. The controversy, he said, is “bigger than student health insurance.” Chelsen added, “I acknowledge that students have been hurt by this decision and I regret that.”
Wheaton is currently litigating the issue in federal courts. The 7th Circuit Court of Appeals recently denied the school’s request for a preliminary injunction against the ACA policy while its case proceeds. Doing some simple, two-page paperwork to claim a religious exemption, the court concluded, “is hardly a burdensome requirement.”
One student told the Chicago Tribune, “I fear the administration is putting petty politics above caring for students.”
Also from the God Machine this week:
* Quite a story out of Chattanooga: “A small group of Christians visited a mosque in Chattanooga to pray alongside Muslim worshippers. The guests who went to the Islamic Society of Greater Chattanooga mosque for prayers on Friday were mainly Baptists, and at least one Presbyterian. One visitor told the Chattanooga Times Free Press they went to the mosque as a show of love for the Muslim community.”
* The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints sponsors a whole lot of Scout troops. That may soon end: “In August, the most senior leaders of the Mormon Church are expected to meet and discuss a decision with profound consequences: whether to end a 100-year relationship with the Boy Scouts of America that has helped shape both institutions.”
* And are we witnessing the end of Christianity in the Middle East? The New York Times Magazine ran an important feature story on this last Sunday.
Recommended
Steve Benen is a producer for "The Rachel Maddow Show," the editor of MaddowBlog and an MS NOW political contributor. He's also the bestselling author of "Ministry of Truth: Democracy, Reality, and the Republicans' War on the Recent Past."