“When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not oppress them. The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt.” (Leviticus 19:33-34)
It was a Tuesday in 2017. Our church marquee read: “#JOSE IS MY NEIGHBOR.” Jose had an asylum case steadily making its way through the court system. However, it turns out that one hand of the justice system, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the immigration police, does not honor the other hand of the justice system: the courts. ICE had told Jose to report to its New Orleans office the next day for deportation — even though he had legal standing.
Jose entered the sanctuary of First Grace UMC, New Orleans, and lived with us for the better part of a year.
That’s why on that Tuesday, Jose, who had spent 10 years helping rebuild New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, left his wife and two small daughters and entered the sanctuary of First Grace UMC, New Orleans, and lived with us for the better part of a year.
During these months, Jose fixed everything: HVAC ducts, pipes, tiles and doors. He prepared meals for the hungry. And he prayed for hours in the sanctuary, repeatedly saying to me, “My life is in God’s hands.” Then, after nine months of living in sanctuary, his lawyer got the call from ICE. They told her to “tell Jose to report to the ICE office. We’ve decided NOT to deport him.”
Seven years later, Jose and his spouse are on track for citizenship. His oldest daughter celebrated her quinceañera this summer. And Jose is the head maintenance person at First Grace UMC.
President-elect Donald Trump has said that he plans to end the policy that generally restricts ICE from arresting undocumented people at or near so-called sensitive locations, including houses of worship, schools and hospitals, or in events such as funerals and weddings. He wants to carry out the largest mass deportation in our country’s history.
What kind of country do we want to be?
Maybe we do want our ICE officers to show up in hospital maternity wards as a mother gives birth. Maybe we do want ICE officers blending into the line at school drop-offs. Maybe we do want them standing in the church narthex, waiting for the benediction (maybe) before pushing through wheelchairs, children and “Amens,” looking for their intended “target.”
Maybe. But many, many of us know — don’t we? — that if we go down that road, something will be lost. That something that is good, eternal and not of our making; that persists and persists and is manifested everywhere, in everyone; something we especially expect to be honored in sacred places. In my tradition we call it the soul. We might just call it the sacredness of an individual life.
Remembering that we have sanctuaries and sacred places is first and foremost not about what you think of the unending, always evolving, national policy debate on immigration. Rather, they demand of us a humility regarding how we will treat the person that is standing right in front of us. Especially the vulnerable: children. The disinherited. As the great American and theologian Howard Thurman put it, the person with their back up against the wall. And, especially how you will treat them in the sacred places where they show up the most: churches, schools and hospitals.
If you want a relationship with Jesus, then have a relationship with the poor, with the disinherited, with the dispossessed. With the immigrant.
Followers of Jesus often speak of having “a personal relationship with Jesus.” Jesus said, “Whatsoever you do to the least, you do unto me.” So, if you want a personal relationship with Jesus, then have a personal relationship with the poor, with the disinherited, with the dispossessed. With the immigrant. With Jose. Then, you will know something about Jesus and yourself. It is humbling, and it is intended to be that way. To get our politics out of our hearts and minds and to get our common humanity front and center.
At First Grace UMC, perhaps the most diverse house of worship in New Orleans, we have a beautiful home for women, their children, and trans women, Hagar’s House. We have a free legal clinic for immigrant children, Project Ishmael. Every week, we go into our neighborhood and serve food. Whenever someone sees that steeple and comes knocking on the door because they are hungry, we feed them. And America, you expect this of us. And, you should expect this of us because we are the church! You expect us not to treat a person the way the law treats a person, or our economy treats a person. You expect us to humble ourselves of all opinions, political persuasions and personal feelings and to care for that person. Even when we fail at it — at being the church, which is often — the next day, someone sees that steeple and comes knocking again to graciously give us the opportunity to be the church again. America, we expect hospital emergency rooms to serve all people, and public schools to serve all children, and houses of worship to care about all people. As we should because we recognize them as sacred places. Don’t we? You expect us not to treat a person the way the law treats a person, or our economy treats a person. For decades, these sacred places in our communities have helped us to honor that sacred something about all of us that is beyond our struggles with policies and even borders. Even the policymakers have understood this, felt it. The prophet Isaiah once invited his people, “Come, let us argue this out together.” In the coming year, let’s “have it out” about immigration policies. Let’s work it out in the statehouse and the White House, but not in the church house. Not on the playground. Not in our hospitals. These sacred places humble us, and in their mysterious way keep us united when we feel so divided. Yes, Jose is my neighbor. And so are you.
Shawn Anglim
Shawn Anglim is the pastor of First Grace United Methodist Church — the merger of a historical Black church and a historical white church in New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. During his leadership, the church established First Grace Community Alliance and its two missions: Hagar's House, a residence for women, trans women and children without homes, and Project Ishmael, a free legal clinic for immigrant children. 
